Arbonne vs Herbalife: [Is Arbonne Better Than Herbalife?]

The main difference between Arbonne and Herbalife is the business model of each company. Arbonne operates as a direct selling company while Herbalife operates as a multi-level marketing company.

Also, they differ in that Arbonne manufactures real food products based on low-sugar ingredients, unlike Herbalife which manufactures supplements based primarily on plant-based proteins.

Arbonne and Herbalife are meal replacement brands that have been in the health and nutrition industry for decades. However, they are quite different.

What is Arbonne?

No products found.

Arbonne is a company that sells beauty and health products. Arbonne offers a range of skincare, makeup, haircare, and other personal care products.

As you can see Arbonne is not a supplement company, although it does have some.

At first glance, Arbonne may seem like just another beauty retailer trying to sell you a new moisturizer or mascara every time you walk into the store.

However, if you dig deeper into Arbonne’s approach to business and marketing, you’ll discover that it’s much more than just another marketing company.

Arbonne Meal Replacement is a meal replacement shake that helps people lose weight and feel better.

The main goal of Arbonne Meal Replacement is to help people reach their weight loss goals. In order to do this, Arbonne Meal Replacement has some key features that make it stand out from the rest.

Arbonne Meal Replacement helps people recover from a meal in just one hour and has a lasting effect of up to 12 hours.

It also uses natural ingredients instead of artificial ones, which means it is completely safe for your body and has no side effects.


  • Easy to mix and tastes good.
  • It is made with pea protein and rice.
  • Contains more than 20 vitamins and minerals.
  • Contains no gluten, artificial sweeteners, cholesterol, soy, or dairy.


  • Arbonne contains folic acid.
  • Does not last long, it will only last 15 days.
  • Expensive.

What is Herbalife?

Herbalife Formula 1 Shake 500G Weight Loss - Mango
  • Lose weight: 2 shakes + 1 normal meal
  • Gain weight: 3 shakes + 3 normal meals
  • Maintain weight: 1 shake + 2 normal meals

Herbalife is a multilevel marketing company that allows its distributors to sell its products. Its main product is the Herbalife Formula 1 shake, which claims to contain all the nutrients necessary for optimal health.

Its other products include meal replacement shakes, energy drinks, protein powder, weight management drinks, etc.

Herbalife has more than 12 million members worldwide, with three million active members in Brazil alone.

It has been criticized by numerous groups for misleading advertising claiming it can help people lose up to five kilos a week without exercise or dieting.

In addition, some have argued that it does not actually provide any benefits for weight loss or other health problems.


  • Herbalife is well-known.
  • It’s delicious.
  • A wide range of tastes is available.


  • This product contains dairy and soy.
  • There is no nutritional information on the package.
  • There is much too much sugar in my diet.
  • Artificial flavorings are present.

Arbonne vs Herbalife Meal Replacement [Table Comparison]

Specs Arbonne Meal Replacement Herbalife Meal Replacement 
Calories210g of calories220g of calories
Protein Content20g (Pea and Rice protein)20g (Soy protein)
Fiber6g of fiber2.3g of fiber
FlavorsRaspberry and blueberry, chocolate and mint, apple with caramel and cinnamon, vanilla, and cookies and cream.Vanilla, Chocolate.
Sugar12 g/serving9 g/serving

What is Similar About Arbonne and Herbalife?

1- Sugar

Both shakes have a lot of sugar in them. For a proper meal, it’s much too high.

2- Multi-level marketing

The businesses are multi-level marketing (MLM) businesses. These are not excellent consumer-friendly business models.

1- Minerals and vitamins

Both vitamins and minerals are of a good grade.

Is Arbonne Better Than Herbalife? [Key Differences]

1- Flavors

Herbalife provides 9 various flavors, including raspberry and blueberry, chocolate and mint, apple with caramel and cinnamon, vanilla, and cookies and cream. Arbonne has just 2 regular flavors, vanilla, and chocolate.

2- Protein content

Both Arbonne and Herbalife have a high protein content, with Herbalife having 20g per serving and Arbonne having 20g per serving.

3- Vitamins and minerals

Arbonne and Herbalife both include a lot of vitamins and minerals.

Herbalife, for example, has 21 vitamins and minerals, including iron, magnesium, phosphorus, and zinc. Vitamins A, B12, B7, B6, B3, B2, B1, and a variety of others are also provided.

In the case of Arbonne, it includes 20 vitamins and minerals, including iron, magnesium, and zinc. Vitamins E, D, A, B, and C are also included.

4- Soy and lactose-free

Arbonne products do not include gluten, artificial sweeteners, cholesterol, soy, or dairy. Herbalife includes precisely 20g of dairy and soy.

5- Price

If you’re on a tight budget, the Arbonne alternative will be prohibitively pricey, costing between $90 and $110.

Herbalife, on the other hand, offers larger bulk rates, ranging about $30-50 for a shake, depending on the amount you compare.


For me, none of them is a viable meal replacement since they are a fraud and are overpriced for what they provide.

Furthermore, both have high sugar content, making them harmful for you.

They include emulsifiers, thickeners, gums, and starches as well.

To be honest, if I had to choose one, I would go with Arbonne since its protein content is of greater quality in my view.

Leave a Comment